The Community Foundation of Randolph County continues to celebrate local heroes who have impacted the community or exceeded expectations to serve others. This effort is the result of a Community Foundation program that helps recognize such people, while also raising money to help others. The program started in 2015, and since that date, this marks the 39th Randolph County Hero nomination. For $1,000 anyone can nominate a person (living or deceased), business, or community organization for the designation of a Randolph County Hero. The money goes into an unrestricted fund, which the Community Foundation uses to do and support great things in Randolph County for years to come. Gifts made to endowed, unrestricted funds, such as the Randolph County Heroes Fund, will be matched $2 dollars for every $1 dollar donated through June 30, 2028, or while matching funds last.
Those designated as Randolph County Heroes will have their names on a plaque at the Foundation office and will be featured in media outlets. The Randolph County Heroes Fund is a great way to honor those currently working to make Randolph County a better place to live or to remember and recognize the impact of someone who has passed. Our newest heroes, Andrew Wagner and Jeremy Duncan, were nominated by Tom and Cathy Stephen Miller.

Andrew “Andy” Wagner Jeremy Duncan
Each year, more than 100 families nominated by Randolph County schools receive a full Christmas – from wrapped presents to Christmas trees and decorations to money for a Christmas dinner alongside necessities such as toothbrushes, shampoo, detergent, and paper products – for everyone in the family. This Christmas, delivered to the families’ homes by a team of trained volunteers who present the family with a Bible and pray for them, comes courtesy of Secret Families of Randolph County, an organization that owes its existence to Andrew “Andy” Wagner and Jeremy Duncan, our newest Randolph County Heroes.
After assisting with the original Secret Families organization in Delaware County, Andy and Jeremy brought the idea to Randolph County 10 years ago and have led the board – and a huge team of volunteers who shop, wrap, and deliver – in this now annual Christmas tradition. Since 2017, the organization has brought love, support, and Christmas cheer to more than 1,000 families in the area.
Not only should they be recognized as Randolph County Heroes for leading this incredible service, but also for the way each of them has live his life, contributing to Randolph County.
Andy has a deep heart for his community, having grown up, lived and worked here his entire life. A 1995 graduate of Monroe Central, Andy enjoyed running, playing basketball, and pulling draft horses with his dad, Max.
After high school graduation, Andy attended the University of Evansville where he studied physical therapy, eventually earning a master’s degree. He went on to work in the field, helping others at First Choice Physical Therapy in Yorktown. Alongside his career in physical therapy, Andy also earned his auctioneer and real estate license.
What began as a weekend business with his dad eventually became his full-time career. In 2010 Andy purchased Reed Realty in Farmland and began building a business centered on serving the people and families of his community.
Andy has a passion for serving, including through the Indiana Auctioneer’s Association, Randolph County 4-H, First Merchants Board, and Monroe Central School Board. In his spare time, he enjoys spending time with his family: wife Abby, son Max, and daughters Cora and Ada. He especially enjoys going to livestock shows and watching his kids compete in various activities. The family also attends Union Chapel Church in Muncie.
Over the years, through Wagner Auctioneering and Real Estate, Andy has assisted countless individuals and families. Through this work he was able to see the need in Randolph County for a program like Secret Families. After volunteering and seeing first-hand the impact Secret Families in Delaware County, Andy assembled a dedicated board and successfully began the program here. His first choice for a board member was Jeremy Duncan.
Jeremy, Andy’s friend and partner in leading Secret Families, is not a Randolph County native but has the same passion for serving and helping the families of this county, where he has resided for over 25 years with his wife Brandy and children Catherine and Carter.
Jeremy was born and raised in Muncie, Indiana and attended Muncie Central High School where he participated in basketball and baseball. He graduated in 1996 and went on to complete multiple degrees in education.
Jeremy has served in many aspects of education, most recently as the superintendent of Fayette County Schools. He taught and coached at Monroe Central, served as principal at Willard Elementary in Winchester, and held the position of superintendent at South Henry (Tri High) schools before transitioning to the same role in Fayette County.
During his time as an educator, Jeremy also served as pastor of the Compass Church in Winchester and continues to this day as a speaker for many other churches. He also has an amazing way of addressing issues in a thoughtful, positive way on Facebook, which has turned into a type of ministry as well.
Jeremy has been very public about his recent battle with stage 4 prostate cancer. He serves as an advocate for early screening. More importantly, he serves as a role model of courage for those battling cancer.
Good people doing great things in our community – Andrew Wagner and Jeremy Duncan are Randolph County Heroes.
